More job seekers are reporting that job descriptions feel vague, inflated, inaccurate, or even suspicious.

A recent r/AskHR thread captured this frustration. Job seekers shared experiences where JDs felt fake, didn’t match the real interview, or never led to a callback.

This blog breaks down the most-upvoted explanations from HR pros and recruiters on Reddit to uncover why job descriptions feel misleading and what talent acquisition teams can take away from the discussion.

The Reddit Thread: What Sparked the Discussion

According to OP’s observation, many JDs feel  “off”: mismatched skills, recycled templates, or roles that may not